Explain the findings
Make the relationship between symptoms and records clearer.
ACL surgery & recovery / Patient guide
ACL injury: when you feel surgery has gone wrong
A careful review of what happened, what the records show and what can help now.
A planned, non-urgent second opinion with Professor Paul Lee
Start with your experience
Making sense of the concern
You may feel that the operation has made things worse, that the result differs from what you expected, or that questions about your care have not been answered. Those concerns deserve to be heard. It helps to separate your current symptoms, the original treatment decision and the sequence of events around surgery.
A disappointing result does not, by itself, establish a technical error or negligence. The role of this consultation is to review the clinical evidence and explain the options for your knee now. If you also need a formal medico-legal assessment, that is a different type of instruction from this clinical appointment.
Connect the evidence
Three parts of the picture
- Step 1
Your concern
What outcome or event has led you to question the surgery?
- Step 2
The evidence
What do the original and subsequent records establish?
- Step 3
The next decision
What could improve the current problem?
A discussion framework, not a diagnostic test or a predicted recovery timeline.
Your clinical second opinion
What the review can explore
Bring the operation report, consent information, pre-operative imaging, subsequent scans and rehabilitation records. Together they can help the discussion move beyond the label “failed surgery”. Explain which symptoms began immediately, which developed later and whether there was another injury.
The review should make clear what is established and what is still uncertain. Ask whether the concern relates to stability, movement, pain, associated injury or another finding. If another operation is proposed, you should understand the specific problem it would address and why it is preferable to the other options being considered.
From explanation to a plan
Possible next steps to discuss
These are directions the conversation may take. They are not a treatment recommendation for every person with these symptoms.
Identify a missing assessment
Resolve an uncertainty before deciding on treatment.
Review further-surgery advice
Discuss its target, alternatives and limitations.
Make the appointment yours
Questions worth bringing
- What can the available evidence tell us about my concern?
- Which parts of the explanation remain uncertain?
- What problem would another operation actually correct?
- Can you separate advice about my current care from questions about past fault?
If the explanation uses an unfamiliar term, ask what it means for your own decision. Before leaving, check who is arranging any next step and how you will receive the results.
Further reading
General patient information supporting the background to this guide. Your individual advice depends on assessment.
Related questions
Explore acl surgery & recovery →Second Opinion Clinic
Talk through your next step.
£100 · 45 minutes · Monthly clinic sessions
Confirm the next clinic date, location and available slot when booking.